The Closest Thing to MJ: Shawn Marion Explains Why Kobe Bryant, Not LeBron, Had the Skill Set of Michael Jordan—And Why the 2007 Horry Foul Was Just a Media ‘Narrative’

Shawn Marion, the four-time All-Star affectionately known as “The Matrix,” recently offered a compelling interview, dissecting the true nature of basketball success, the influence of media narratives on players like Jason Kidd and Ben Simmons, and the critical role of the supporting cast in securing championships.

The Power of Narrative: Defending Simmons and Kidd

Marion opened up about how media perception often overshadows reality in the NBA, specifically addressing the critiques of Ben Simmons’ and Jason Kidd’s lack of shooting.

“That’s because the media created the narrative,” Marion said, dismissing the long-standing critique of Kidd. He applied the same logic to Simmons, whom he spoke with recently in Los Angeles.

Marion’s advice to the struggling Simmons was direct: “Don’t be listening to the media, man… don’t go out here and buy into the media. Just go out there and play your game.” He emphasized that Simmons is “too talented of a player” to let outside noise derail his career. While he recognized there are “a lot of stuff that goes on behind the scenes of organizations that we don’t know of,” Marion hopes Simmons finds a resolution that benefits both him and his organization.

Championships Are Not Won by a Star Alone

Marion pushed back strongly against the idea that the 2007 Phoenix Suns’ Western Conference Semifinals loss to the Spurs—following the Robert Horry foul on Steve Nash and subsequent suspensions—was an automatic lost opportunity.

“No, because that’s a narrative that the media created,” he said. He stressed that 2007 wasn’t even the Suns’ best season. He offered a deeper analysis of winning:

“You don’t win off your stars; you’re only going to go as far as your bench can take you. That’s how these championships are won.”

Marion used his own 2011 Dallas Mavericks title run to illustrate the point. He rejected the narrative that it was “all Dirk [Nowitzki],” emphasizing the crucial contributions of himself, Jason Kidd, Jason Terry, Tyson Chandler, and Brendan Haywood. “It’s a collective team win and that’s why we won that championship because we were a big team. It’s not about individuals.”

Stephon Marbury and the Hall of Fame Criteria

Marion reflected on his time playing with Stephon Marbury in Phoenix, calling him an “AMAZING athlete and an amazing point guard.” He believes Marbury should be considered for the Hall of Fame, especially given his successful career overseas, where he became a global star and even had a statue built in his honor.

Marion questioned the integrity of the Hall’s selection process: “What is the criteria for the Hall of Fame? Is it a popularity contest or is it people really going out there and making an impact on the game?” He and Marbury remain close, sharing fried chicken and reminiscing about their time together, proving their relationship had a “cool dynamic” despite any past issues.

The GOAT Debate: Skill Set vs. Athleticism

Marion, having played against Michael Jordan, Kobe Bryant, and LeBron James, offered a unique perspective on the perennial GOAT debate, advocating that Kobe was the closest player to Jordan in terms of skill and mentality.

“Kobe emulated everything MJ did on the court; from the fadeaway to all that other stuff and he truly patented his game after MJ,” Marion said.

He distinguished LeBron from the other two by his unique athleticism and playmaking: “LeBron is a different type of player. I mean, athletic-wise when you look at LeBron you don’t look at him as a scorer-scorer because he does everything on the floor.”

Marion urged fans to simply appreciate greatness across generations: “Stop trying to compare the two… I think MJ is in his own lane just as well as LeBron is in his own lane.” He reiterated that, when assessing skill set and mentality, Kobe is the “CLOSEST thing to MJ.”

The Matrix Legacy

Looking back at his own career, Marion stated that he sees no modern equivalent to his unique, versatile game.

He once compared himself to a younger Kawhi Leonard, noting Leonard also plays both ends of the floor and “never gets tired.” However, Marion ultimately believes Leonard lacks his same level of athleticism.

Marion is content with his legacy, knowing he left an imprint on the game as a multi-skilled winner. “Everywhere I went in my career, I was winning games,” he concluded. “I was able to leave an imprint on the game that is a big presence of what the game is right now.”

Share:

Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
LinkedIn

Brandon ‘Scoop B’ Robinson is the host of the Scoop B Radio Podcast. A senior writer at Basketball Society, he’s had stops as a staff writer at The Source Magazine, as a columnist and podcast host at CBS and as an editor at RESPECT. Magazine. In his downtime, he enjoys traveling, swimming and finding new sushi restaurants.

Follow Brandon ‘Scoop B’ Robinson on Twitter: @ScoopB, Instagram: @Scoop_B & Facebook: ScoopB.

Make sure to visit: www.ScoopB.com & www.ScoopBRadio.com for more info.

Author: admin

Brandon ‘Scoop B’ Robinson is a columnist at Basketball Society. Follow him on Twitter: @ScoopB and Instagram: @Scoop_B. As a 12 year old, he was a Nets reporter from 1997-1999, co-hosting a show called Nets Slammin’ Planet with former Nets legend, Albert King, WFAN’s Evan Roberts and Nets play-by-play man Chris Carrino. Scoop B has also been a writer and radio host at CBS, a staff writer at The Source Magazine and managing editor/columnist at RESPECT Magazine. He’s a graduate of Don Bosco Prep, Eastern University and Hofstra University. You can catch him daily on the Scoop B Radio Podcast. Visit ScoopBRadio.com to listen. For inquiries and to contact Brandon ‘Scoop B’ Robinson visit ScoopB.com